Definitely needs some Fire Emblem game on here, but Radiant Dawn is arguably the worst / second worst (behind Sacred Stones). Fire Emblem 4 (Holy War) is my personal favorite, but Thracia probably has the best gameplay. If we wanted to nominate an English Fire Emblem, I would go with Fire Emblem 7 or Path of Radiance. I would assume Fire Emblem 7 would be the highest ranked English one.
I would nominate:
Fire Emblem Genealogy of the Holy War
Fire Emblem Thracia 776
Fire Emblem Blazing Sword
Are we nominating online games as well? If so I will nominate:
Guild Wars
Finally, while I don't think too many sports games should make the list, the best one I want to nominate is:
NBA Street