What makes you think there's another igniter?
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
NOC Bard's College Mafia - Day Three
- Thread starter acidphoenix
- Start date
- Status
Thetwinmasters(9): Prophylaxis, Texas Cloverleaf, Former Hope, Hitmonleet, Earlio, bluedoom, Metal Sonic, bloodyrain10001, aura guardian
Hitmonleet(4): MoodyCloud, Thetwinmasters, Haruno, Asek
Metal Sonic(1): XnadrojX
Granny Pie(1): MeowMIXXX
Abstain (3): Jalmont, Champ1604, Granny Pie
Questions to people:
1) If there is scum on the thetwinmasters train (people bussing and stuff) then who would be the person bussing?
2) If there is scum pushing the Hitmonleet counterwagon other than TTM, who would that person be?
3) Out of the people NOT on the main wagons (Xnadroj, MeowMixx, Jalmont, Champ/GP) who is town and who is scum? (Ignore Champ/GP I guess, they are self resolving)
Hitmonleet(4): MoodyCloud, Thetwinmasters, Haruno, Asek
Metal Sonic(1): XnadrojX
Granny Pie(1): MeowMIXXX
Abstain (3): Jalmont, Champ1604, Granny Pie
Questions to people:
1) If there is scum on the thetwinmasters train (people bussing and stuff) then who would be the person bussing?
2) If there is scum pushing the Hitmonleet counterwagon other than TTM, who would that person be?
3) Out of the people NOT on the main wagons (Xnadroj, MeowMixx, Jalmont, Champ/GP) who is town and who is scum? (Ignore Champ/GP I guess, they are self resolving)
I know there's another douser
Wrt 1 I looked at late wagon flippers to see who moved from which wagon to which but didn't get anything conclusive other than AG is still sketch
Wrt 2 asek
Wrt 3 kill em all imo
wrt proph 1-3
IIRC Former Hope was cleared by something re: Proph, and with me now clear via Jalmont:
If me scum, then Jalmont; if Jalmont not scum then not me
If Former scum, then Proph; if not Proph then not Former
So on twin, not clear by power: Proph, Texas, Hitmonleet, Earlio, bluedoom, Metal Sonic, bloodyrain10001
off twin but same person as him: MoodyCloud, Haurno, Asek
off twin, not same person: XnadrojX, MeowMiXXX
off all wagons, self-resolving: Champ1604, Granny Pie
off all wagons, not self-resolving: Jalmont
Twin was fond of throwing shade on Hitmonleet (and haruno/jalmont to a lesser degree) and Proph/Texas/Leet were the early voters. If someone were on the Twin wagon, they'd probably be later to the party - indeed, making the mafia think I would be a great patsy today was part of why I delayed my swap to so late (so I could get my power off without a hitch). So, I think low-odds Earlio or bluedoom, more likely Metal Sonic or bloodyrain10001. Though all four could be it - maybe one of earlio/blue and one of MS/bloody.
Off the wagon, I still like MeowMiXXX for mafia. Others off the wagon are: wait and see for self-resolving.
IIRC Former Hope was cleared by something re: Proph, and with me now clear via Jalmont:
If me scum, then Jalmont; if Jalmont not scum then not me
If Former scum, then Proph; if not Proph then not Former
So on twin, not clear by power: Proph, Texas, Hitmonleet, Earlio, bluedoom, Metal Sonic, bloodyrain10001
off twin but same person as him: MoodyCloud, Haurno, Asek
off twin, not same person: XnadrojX, MeowMiXXX
off all wagons, self-resolving: Champ1604, Granny Pie
off all wagons, not self-resolving: Jalmont
Twin was fond of throwing shade on Hitmonleet (and haruno/jalmont to a lesser degree) and Proph/Texas/Leet were the early voters. If someone were on the Twin wagon, they'd probably be later to the party - indeed, making the mafia think I would be a great patsy today was part of why I delayed my swap to so late (so I could get my power off without a hitch). So, I think low-odds Earlio or bluedoom, more likely Metal Sonic or bloodyrain10001. Though all four could be it - maybe one of earlio/blue and one of MS/bloody.
Off the wagon, I still like MeowMiXXX for mafia. Others off the wagon are: wait and see for self-resolving.
Dude you're not even close to clear
Former hope pretty much is though, kind of insane to expect him to pull the Toni theory he did if they're scum buddies
Former hope pretty much is though, kind of insane to expect him to pull the Toni theory he did if they're scum buddies
I'm kind of fine doing this for now though
Vote bloodyrain
Vote bloodyrain
Want to see this slot be more proactive, the town read I had on them waned pretty consistently through d2
It's called friendly neighbor.
Convincing, but not a clear nonetheless
Whoops got that mixed up with neighbourizer
For the threads benefit friendly neighbor makes you tell someone that you're town
So, very convincing, but not a full clear in the event you're both scum doing scum theatre
For the threads benefit friendly neighbor makes you tell someone that you're town
So, very convincing, but not a full clear in the event you're both scum doing scum theatre
leet, there's no reason Haruno losing their abilities and them regaining them is the same action
they said they had a cop ability which would means the mafia would be pretty likely to erase their abilities and that other town may be likely to try and give them another shot
also, for Proph
1. Maybe AG? The vote seems to be started by solid town (Proph, Texas, Hitmonleet) and I don't recall anything sus about the other people jumping onto the vote. I have prior suspicion of AG so that's the only real reason I'd put them down here.
2. I think Haruno is town and twin is scum, not sure about Moody and Asek, so I suppose they'd be the two possible candidates. Moody was on before leet claimed and Asek after, right? In that case, Asek.
3. Jalmont: Town read based on his fight with Texas earlier
Xnad: I just glanced over all of his posts and none of them really stand out to me. Neutral read at the moment? Or does it default to light town read in this case?
Meow: Not much of a read here either besides me disliking his post some time yesterday that more or less said that there's no point in lynch metal because you can't tell what alignment he is no matter how he plays. I disagree with this because it's essentially just clearing Metal as town for no reason. [in the sense that clearing means you won't be voted]
they said they had a cop ability which would means the mafia would be pretty likely to erase their abilities and that other town may be likely to try and give them another shot
also, for Proph
1. Maybe AG? The vote seems to be started by solid town (Proph, Texas, Hitmonleet) and I don't recall anything sus about the other people jumping onto the vote. I have prior suspicion of AG so that's the only real reason I'd put them down here.
2. I think Haruno is town and twin is scum, not sure about Moody and Asek, so I suppose they'd be the two possible candidates. Moody was on before leet claimed and Asek after, right? In that case, Asek.
3. Jalmont: Town read based on his fight with Texas earlier
Xnad: I just glanced over all of his posts and none of them really stand out to me. Neutral read at the moment? Or does it default to light town read in this case?
Meow: Not much of a read here either besides me disliking his post some time yesterday that more or less said that there's no point in lynch metal because you can't tell what alignment he is no matter how he plays. I disagree with this because it's essentially just clearing Metal as town for no reason. [in the sense that clearing means you won't be voted]
OK I'm here, writing my PoE the gamestate out post. If you guys need anything, ask.
Uhm the action I used last night was refunded, so I guess someone reloaded me?
Vote Metal Sonic
I stand by my vote from yesterday, also they haven't done anything more that indicates them as town. Before you throw the meta argument at me, he was also being very anti-town in WWI mafia, where he was indeed scum, so I'm pretty sure his scumgame can go like that.
Vote Metal Sonic
I stand by my vote from yesterday, also they haven't done anything more that indicates them as town. Before you throw the meta argument at me, he was also being very anti-town in WWI mafia, where he was indeed scum, so I'm pretty sure his scumgame can go like that.
Actually I'll try to write it all up tomorrow; I've been composing this entire thing in my notes and I definitely need to be more awake to write this all up in a coherent fashion.
Just some off the cuff notes:
- I believe AG's claim but I'm a little wary about all of the townclears that are popping up. First Texas, now AG. I guess a cop one shot plus a friendly neighbor one shot isn't too much but it's something we should remain vigilant about if it turns out the PoE is poisoned or something.
- Slots I have no idea about right now: Earlio, Bloodyrain, MoodyCloud, XnadrojX, probably throw Jalmont in the mix. I need to reread the entire game to figure out how I feel about those slots and evaluate how they reacted to TTM.
Vote Asek
Just looked back at the last couple of pages and probably scum trying to push the Hitmonleet counterwagon to scum TTM? His posts make me crack up but getting paranoid of his EoD behavior
Just some off the cuff notes:
- I believe AG's claim but I'm a little wary about all of the townclears that are popping up. First Texas, now AG. I guess a cop one shot plus a friendly neighbor one shot isn't too much but it's something we should remain vigilant about if it turns out the PoE is poisoned or something.
- Slots I have no idea about right now: Earlio, Bloodyrain, MoodyCloud, XnadrojX, probably throw Jalmont in the mix. I need to reread the entire game to figure out how I feel about those slots and evaluate how they reacted to TTM.
Vote Asek
Just looked back at the last couple of pages and probably scum trying to push the Hitmonleet counterwagon to scum TTM? His posts make me crack up but getting paranoid of his EoD behavior
the flip doesn't change /anything/ for you? you still believe metal sonic is scum even when you have a scum flip on your hands?
complete lack of adjustment based on a scum flip is.. unsettling, to say the least
tell me who you think TTM's buddies are at the moment
can't get complacent, we have four more scum to drill through. complacency loses villager games
any reasoning for any of these reads or is it just a shoot-from-the-hip scumteam guess
specifically interested in your reasoning for jordan/earlio, they are the slots that i've been having difficulty reading
thoughts on moodycloud?
all in due time
need to actually reread and look at TTM interactions to solve the game here
let's say that there's one scum 100% on the ttm wagon, who do you think it was? (i'm assuming scum is bussing here since if 4 of the scum are off wagon then this game will be really easy)
do you think aesk is scum?
i like killing them all
i'm actually getting somewhat paranoid about FH selling his buddy out like that after how /accurate/ it was
what do you think?
1. AG is confirmed town via friendly neighbor, who else do you think is scum
2. thoughts on asek's alignment? thoughts on MoodyCloud's alignment?
3. moreover can you ask some people questions? like Texas here I really want to see some more proactivity come out of your slot. Precarious was like this all in game 9 and we eventually lynched him for it at the end of the game. he flipped scum. i am getting similar vibes out of you (not really engaging in major conversation, popping up every couple of days with a big post)
Asek/Xnadroj/(champ/GP)/Y is where I'm at right now
Y is probably someone pocketing me hard right now/in my townreads, but not worth figuring out right now
Y is probably someone pocketing me hard right now/in my townreads, but not worth figuring out right now
- Status