Asek can you explain why Champ is a town read please because I don't think you did.
Champ needs to stop with the setup spec and have an actual opinion on what's going on right now. Giving mafia any information about roles is a bad thing and it's suspect that you're still pushing it as an ok thing to do.
Then on top of that your point 2 is actually nonsense:
What's towny about a person claiming VT when under pressure? If you answer is "I never said that a person claiming VT under pressure is towny" then sorry it's my fault for being a vt.
How does this makes any sense? Why are you asking him this when you know he's gonna respond with that statement, and how does "being a VT" counter the point? Claiming VT when under pressure D1 is usually townie because if there's a wagon on you as scum then claiming VT doesn't save you (9/10). I have a bad feeling you're gonna just respond to this without posting reads though so post them, last chance.
Now on the other hand, if you're about to get shot then you want a claim that is as safe s possible, and what better for that than doc? Completely unprovable in this setup, strong enough to discourage a lynch, and especially strong enough to discourage day vigs (which was what was threatened). Since there's a decent chance he's not the only doc/protection we have (RB counts as protection I think) and he still hasn't given any reads other than outdated stuff on Twin I'm still good to lynch here.
I think it's unlikely that roles can't target consecutively, that would probably be mentioned in the mechanics in an open setup since it's not normal
the doc claim is probably town imo. the claim in reaction to the dayvig joke reads like panicked newbtown. I think newbscum would ask for advice and wouldn't have claimed so fast.
feels like asek is avoiding giving an opinion
I'm pretty sure Durza said he wasn't a newb? He might've mostly played chatroom mafia but the concepts should still be similar unless turbo wagons are really popular on that format or something which I admittedly don't know about, have you played it? I dunno feels like you're trying real hard to cut off criticism from him, why would scum not panic too at the thought of being dayvigged?
All this said I am pretty good to lynch Earlio too, this is like the fourth time they drove by to put a vote on a current wagon with only one line of justification.
I'm much better with Fenrir after his recent posts. Nothing disagreeable and some good points, especially about acid. Annoying that it took this long to get it but w/e, could use a consolidated reads list from him though as it's hard to track his scumreads. Same with acidphoenix really but with worse content, he chastises Durza for claiming only a day into the thread when Durza was threatened with a dayvig and doesn't give his thoughts on if that is a town claim or a scum claim. It seemed like he had an opinion on Durza before yet is sorta just letting what happens happen.
Durza > Earlio >>>> Champ > Acid Phoenix